Custom GPT vs Claude Projects vs Gems: Set Up a Saved Assistant

Custom GPTs and Gems are changing. Learn when a saved assistant beats a fresh chat, what to put in its instructions and files, and which tool fits your work.

If you paste the same background into a chat every time (who your clients are, how you like things written, the template you always use), you're doing work a saved assistant could do for you. ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini each let you save instructions and files so every new chat starts out already knowing your work. In this guide you'll learn which of these tools is still worth setting up (two well-known ones are changing), when a saved assistant beats a fresh chat, what to put in its instructions and files, and what a setup looks like for three common roles.

First, what's changing as of November 2026

Most comparisons of custom GPTs vs Claude Projects were written before two big changes. Check these before you spend an afternoon on setup.

  • Gemini Gems are becoming skills. Google's Gems help page says that starting in November 2026, Gems will go away on personal Google accounts and automatically turn into skills. A third-party guide says supported files carry over, which suggests unsupported ones may not. Google's notice doesn't say what happens on work or school (Workspace) accounts.
  • Custom GPTs are reportedly being retired in favour of plugins. Third-party guides, including this walkthrough, report that since September 16, 2026, new custom GPTs can only be created inside ChatGPT Business, Enterprise, or Edu workspaces that allow it, and that GPTs will migrate to plugins. We couldn't confirm the details on OpenAI's own pages, so check OpenAI's help center for the dates that apply to your plan.
  • Claude Projects has a new version in beta. Anthropic's Projects help page describes threads that keep running after you close your laptop, and a Library that collects the files you add and the files Claude produces. Existing projects keep their instructions, files, chat history, and scheduled tasks.

So for most people the useful comparison today is ChatGPT Projects vs Claude Projects vs Gemini Gems (soon skills). The good news: everything below about instructions and files works in all of them.

When a saved assistant beats a fresh chat

A saved assistant pays off when you'd otherwise restate the same background every time. That's how OpenAI frames ChatGPT Projects. Set one up when:

  • You do the same task every week, like client replies, status reports, or meeting follow-ups.
  • The task depends on the same reference material: a style guide, a price sheet, a policy handbook.
  • You want a consistent tone or format without explaining it again.
  • Several people on a team need the same answers from the same documents.

Stick with a fresh chat for one-off questions, quick brainstorming, or anything unrelated to your saved material. Old instructions can pull a new task in the wrong direction. If you're still choosing an assistant in the first place, start with Which AI Assistant Should I Use?.

ChatGPT Projects, Claude Projects, and Gems compared

ChatGPT Projects

A project holds chats, files, and instructions in one place, so you don't restate background in each chat. You can move existing chats in and invite collaborators if your plan allows sharing. A third-party guide reports file limits per project of 5 on Free, 25 on Go and Plus, and 40 on Pro, Business, and Enterprise, as of November 2026, and says you can add Google Drive and Slack links as sources. Good at: keeping related chats together. Watch out for: the small file allowance on the Free plan.

Claude Projects

Create one at claude.ai/projects with + New Project, then click Set project instructions. Those instructions apply to every chat in the project. Two details from Anthropic's help center matter a lot. Claude can't see the project's name or description, so anything important belongs in the instructions. And chats in a project don't share context with each other unless you add that material to project knowledge. On paid plans, when your files approach the context limit, Claude switches to a retrieval mode so it can work with more material. Good at: long reference documents. Watch out for: sharing is limited to Team and Enterprise plans.

Gemini Gems (becoming skills)

Go to gemini.google.com, open Gems, choose New Gem, add a name and instructions, optionally add Knowledge files, and save. According to Google's help page, you can only create or edit Gems on the web, but you can use them in the mobile app and the Workspace side panel (not in Gemini Live). A third-party guide says knowledge can come from uploads, Google Drive files, and NotebookLM notebooks. Good at: fitting in if your work already lives in Google Workspace. Watch out for: the move to skills, which may change how things work.

One note on custom GPTs: their main advantage was Actions, which could call outside services. If your team relied on those, wait for OpenAI's official migration guidance rather than rebuilding elsewhere in a hurry.

What to put in the instructions

Instructions are the standing brief the assistant reads before every chat. Write them the way you'd brief a capable new colleague. Cover these five things:

  1. Who it's helping and who reads the output. Your role, your team, your audience.
  2. The job. The one recurring task this assistant handles.
  3. Tone and format. Length, structure, reading level, words to avoid.
  4. How to use the files. Name each file and say when to use it.
  5. What to do when unsure. Ask you a question, or say it couldn't find the answer.

Keep each assistant focused on one recurring task. A catch-all assistant with ten jobs ends up with instructions that contradict each other. For more on writing clear briefs, see How to Write a Good AI Prompt.

Instruction template for any saved assistant
You help [your role] at [company], which [what the company does]. Your job is to [one recurring task]. The people who read your output are [audience], who care about [what they care about].

Tone: [e.g., warm, plain, no jargon]. Format: [e.g., under 150 words, short paragraphs, one clear next step at the end].

Use the uploaded files: [file name] for [purpose], [file name] for [purpose]. Prefer them over general knowledge.

If you need information you don't have, ask me one question before drafting. Never invent prices, dates, names, or policies.

What to put in the files

Files give the assistant facts and examples it can't guess. Good candidates include:

  • Your style guide, or a one-page summary of how you like things written.
  • Templates you reuse: a status report, a proposal outline, a reply format.
  • Three to five examples of past work you were happy with.
  • Reference facts: product sheets, FAQs, policies, process documents.

A few habits make files work better:

  • Use clear, descriptive file names, like Refund-Policy-2026.pdf instead of doc3.pdf, so the assistant finds the right material and you can point to it by name.
  • Combine related material into fewer, larger files if you're close to a file limit.
  • Name an owner for any shared assistant, so someone keeps the files current.
  • Keep a master copy of your instructions and files in a folder you own. Setups don't move between tools, and the changes above show why that matters.

Three examples for common roles

Adapt these starting points. Paste the instructions into your tool's instruction field, then upload the files listed.

Account manager: client email replies

Files: your services overview, your current price list, and a document with five past replies you liked.

Instructions: client reply assistant
You help me reply to client emails as an account manager at [company]. Clients are [type of client], usually busy and short on time. Use `Services-Overview.pdf` for what we offer and `Price-List-2026.pdf` for prices. Never quote a price that isn't in that file. Match the tone of the replies in `Example-Replies.docx`: friendly, direct, no exclamation marks. Keep replies under 150 words with one clear next step. When I paste a client email, first list any questions the files don't answer, then draft the reply.

HR or operations: policy questions

Files: the employee handbook, benefits summary, and leave policy, each as a separate, clearly named file. This setup uses grounding wording so the assistant declines rather than guesses.

Instructions: policy Q&A assistant
You answer employee questions about [company]'s policies. Answer using only the uploaded files. For every answer, name the file and section you used. If the answer is not in the files, say you could not find it and suggest contacting [HR contact]. Do not give legal advice or interpret policies beyond what the files say. Keep answers under 120 words, in plain language.

Project manager: weekly status reports

Files: your status report template and the project plan. Each week, open a new chat and paste in your rough notes. Because Claude doesn't carry context between chats in a project, add a running decisions log to the files if the assistant needs history.

Instructions: status report assistant
You turn my rough weekly notes into a status report for [project] using the template in `Status-Template.docx`. Readers are [sponsor or leadership], who read on their phones and want the bottom line first. Structure: overall status (on track, at risk, or off track) with one sentence explaining why, then progress this week, plans for next week, and risks or decisions needed. Flag any date or budget in my notes that conflicts with `Project-Plan.pdf`. Don't add progress I didn't mention.

Test it before you rely on it

Spend ten minutes testing before you share an assistant or trust it with real work.

  1. Check you're inside the right project or Gem. A common reason for 'it ignored my files' is chatting outside it. If it still ignores them, add a line to the instructions telling it to use the uploaded files.
  2. Ask three questions the files answer. Check that each answer is correct and names the right file.
  3. Ask one question the files don't answer. A good setup says it couldn't find the answer instead of inventing one.
  4. Don't assume it remembers earlier chats. Claude doesn't share context between chats in a project unless it's in project knowledge. Put anything the assistant should always know into the files.
  5. Revisit it monthly. Update files when prices or policies change, and tighten the instructions when you spot repeated mistakes.

Made-up details can still slip through. AI Hallucinations: How to Avoid Them shows how to catch them before they reach a client or colleague.

Questions people ask

Can I still create a custom GPT?

Several third-party guides report that since September 16, 2026, new custom GPTs can only be created in ChatGPT Business, Enterprise, or Edu workspaces that allow it, and that custom GPTs are being retired in favour of plugins. We couldn't confirm this on OpenAI's own pages, so check OpenAI's help center. For most people, ChatGPT Projects is the practical alternative.

What is the difference between custom GPTs and Claude Projects?

Both save instructions and files so you don't repeat background in every chat. Custom GPTs could also use Actions to call outside services, which Claude Projects has no direct equivalent for, according to one comparison. Claude Projects keep related chats together and, on paid plans, switch to a retrieval mode when you add a lot of material.

What happens to my Gemini Gems?

Google says that starting in November 2026, Gems on personal Google accounts will automatically turn into skills. A third-party guide says supported files carry over, so download your Knowledge files and copy your instructions first. Google's notice doesn't cover work or school accounts.

Does a Claude Project remember previous chats?

Not by default. Anthropic says context isn't shared between chats in a project unless you add it to project knowledge. Save anything the assistant should always know as a file in the project.

Sources

  1. Google Gemini Help: Gems
  2. Claude Help Center: What are projects?
  3. Claude Help Center: How can I create and manage projects?
  4. OpenAI Academy: Projects
  5. Fastero: ChatGPT Projects guide
  6. AI Toolbox: How to create custom GPTs (2026 walkthrough)
  7. Merlin: What are Gemini Gems (2026)
  8. DEV Community: Claude Projects, set up a shared team knowledge base
  9. My Writing Twin: ChatGPT Projects complete guide

Written with AI assistance and checked against the sources above. AI tools change quickly, so confirm features and prices on each vendor's site.

What did you think?

Join the conversation

Do you have a saved assistant you use every week? Which tool is it in, and what job does it do for you?

Want help putting this to work?

Promptly Taught offers hands-on AI training for people and teams, online or in person. Bring a real problem and leave with something that works.

Keep learning